Why Morgan Stanley is overweight passive in this volatile environment

Why Morgan Stanley is overweight passive in this volatile environment

We all know the stats. Over the long term, the majority of active investment managers will underperform their benchmarks. 

According to SPIVA data, more than 78% of funds underperformed the S&P/ASX 200 over the past decade, while more than 91% of funds underperformed the S&P 500 over the same time period. These rates improve significantly over shorter time horizons, with 42% of Aussie managers outperforming their benchmark over a one-year period, and 49% of US-based managers doing the same. 

Given the volatility of today’s market, and his own findings from more than 15 years specialising in asset allocation in global and Australian markets, Morgan Stanley Wealth Management’s Head of Research and Investment Strategy Alexandre Ventelon believes investors should remain conservatively positioned. 

This means a greater emphasis on (and portfolio allocation to) fixed income markets, but also, a greater reliance on passive products – like index-tracking exchange-traded funds (ETFs) – as we continue to navigate this short-term volatility. And right now, Morgan Stanley’s model portfolios are heavily skewed towards passive products. 

“With a short timeline, the best way to get there is with a passive instrument,” Ventelon explains. 
“The managers that have outperformed their markets on a one-year basis are often very different from one year to the other, and that’s the issue. If you want to go with a tactical trade and you just choose one manager, based on how they performed last year, the odds will be against you.” 

In this special Listed Series special of The Rules of Investing podcast, Livewire’s Ally Selby learns which asset exposures are best played with passive products in today’s market, the circumstances in which passive and active products should not be used, as well as Morgan Stanley’s outlook on the ETF market over the next decade.  

Ventelon also shares why Morgan Stanley still remains bullish on the outlook for bonds. Plus, for a little bit of fun, we asked him to build a portfolio of listed products for the market today, while only picking one ETF from each asset class. 

Timestamps

2:12 – How efficient the market is today 

5:37 – How passive funds have changed the world of investing 

8:12 – Are passive or active products better suited to today’s market 

13:22 – The instances where passive products should not be used in portfolios 

18:17 – The instances where active products should not be used in portfolios 

24:42 – Criticisms of passive products – do they hold any weight? 

28:20 – What the market will look like in 10 years’ time

33:53 – Why Morgan Stanley is bullish on bonds (and why he is using VGB, VIF and VACF to play it) 

38:45 – Ventelon’s top ETFs for today’s market (A200, WVOL, QUAL, VGB and VIF) 

Show More

Backward
Play
Forward
1x speed
  • 0.5
  • 1
  • 1.5
  • 2
Other episodes
Blackwattle’s Ray David is raising red flags about market darling CSL

Blackwattle’s Ray David is raising red flags about market darling CSL

There are a select few stocks on the ASX that boast true market darling status. Whereas other stocks sell off at the hint of bad news, market darlings seem to emit an aura effect on markets that itself attracts investment.
Biotech company CSL is argu...

346 downloads Rules of Investing Aug 18, 2023
44m
Trailer: Blackwattle’s Ray David is raising red flags about market darling CSL

Trailer: Blackwattle’s Ray David is raising red flags about market darling CSL

Hello and welcome to the Rules of Investing, brought to you by Livewire Markets, I’m your host David Thornton.
On the upcoming episode I sit down with Ray David, Portfolio Manager and Partner at Blackwattle Investment Partners. Alongside Joseph Koh, ...

333 downloads Rules of Investing Aug 16, 2023
3m
Livewire Live is back in 2023!

Livewire Live is back in 2023!

Livewire Live is an investor event like no other where Australia’s most experienced investors will debate the critical topics in markets right now.
It is set to be an unmissable event with an exceptional lineup of speakers and innovative formats. Tic...

346 downloads Rules of Investing Aug 16, 2023
7m
What do counting cars and delivering an 18% pa return for investors have in common?

What do counting cars and delivering an 18% pa return for investors have in common?

There is a good reason why Australia’s sovereign wealth fund, the Future Fund, maintains a 16% allocation to private equity. Returns, returns, returns.
Private equity, and the lucrative returns it offers, has traditionally been the restricted domain ...

397 downloads Rules of Investing Aug 11, 2023
45m
Regal’s ultimate guide to microcap investing in 2023

Regal’s ultimate guide to microcap investing in 2023

If there is one request that we repeatedly receive from our audience, it’s that you want more content on the wonderful, often under-covered world of microcaps. 
It makes cents (literally). These stocks usually fly under the radar of the masses, provi...

262 downloads Rules of Investing Aug 04, 2023
39m
Trailer: The ultimate guide to microcap investing in 2023

Trailer: The ultimate guide to microcap investing in 2023

In the upcoming episode of The Rules of Investing, we're joined by microcap expert Jessica Farr-Jones, the portfolio manager of the Regal Emerging Companies Strategy*.
She shares why she is feeling bullish about the opportunity in small and micro cap...

332 downloads Rules of Investing Aug 02, 2023
1m
The only ASX stock with a return on equity of over 50%

The only ASX stock with a return on equity of over 50%

Value investing is all about buying stocks that are trading below their intrinsic value. 
In practical terms, that often involves investing in companies and sectors that have been shunned by the market due to particular macro headwinds. 
"It should b...

294 downloads Rules of Investing Jul 28, 2023
48m
Oscar Oberg: Small caps are primed to rally, and it doesn’t happen without these stocks

Oscar Oberg: Small caps are primed to rally, and it doesn’t happen without these stocks

A year ago I sat down with Oscar Oberg, lead portfolio manager at Wilson Asset Management. His thesis then was that small caps were beaten down and due some mean reversion.
Alas, small caps haven’t done much since then, with the Small Ords returning ...

348 downloads Rules of Investing Jul 21, 2023
42m
Trailer: Small caps are primed to rally, and it doesn’t happen without these stocks

Trailer: Small caps are primed to rally, and it doesn’t happen without these stocks

Hello and welcome to the rules of investing, brought to you by Livewire Markets. I’m your host David Thornton.
A year ago I sat down with Oscar Oberg, lead portfolio manager at Wilson Asset Management. His thesis then was that small caps were beaten ...

287 downloads Rules of Investing Jul 19, 2023
2m
Suggested Stories

Who would have guessed laws required companies to request...

DisinterestedSep 25, 2022
0 mins read

The question of whether abortion should be legal has been...

DanielJun 26, 2022
4 mins read

Four-time major winner Brooks Koepka has also left the PG...

sportislife15Jun 26, 2022
0 mins read

The subsidisation of unreliable “renewable” power is why ...

DisinterestedJun 19, 2022
0 mins read

LIV Golf is off to a good start, whatever the PGA Tour an...

sportislife15Jun 11, 2022
4 mins read

All governments eventually lose power, but the Liberal Pa...

DanielMay 29, 2022
4 mins read